Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mallory's avatar

My best recommendation is to get a big roll of white or brown paper, cover the kitchen table with it, put out art supplies and let them color/draw directly on it. It keeps them occupied for so much longer than single sheets of paper and they feel like they're getting away with something by "coloring on the table"!

Tran Hung Dao's avatar

I hate that AAP statement on trampolines so much. It is a capsule of everything that is wrong with modern parenting advice.

When I checked the same number of kids are hospitalised for bicycle accidents as trampoline accidents. Obviously the *rate* will be different since way more kids bicycle than jump on trampolines. But the AAP statement doesn't say anything about rates, only about total numbers. So playing by their game, bicycles are also too dangerous for children.

But like most modern parenting advice the AAP 1) gives a free pass to anything considered "normal" (e.g. riding a bicycle) while anything considered new or different is help up to an impossibly high standard. (See also: "don't eat sushi while pregnant".)

But 2) there's also no discussion of cost-benefit. There is implicitly assumed to be zero benefit, thus no risk is tolerable. But your kids being able to independently play in a physical way in your own backyard or even a relatively small patio is huge! How many other options are there that tick all those boxes?

Trampolines are the very definition of "risky play" and the AAP should be giving guidance on how to do it more safely. Not telling parents to avoid them at all costs. Just look at the framing: are they "safe". What does "safe" even mean? Zero accidents ever?

I'm pretty sure cars hurt way more kids than trampolines, anyway.

16 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?